Sub Jay's

Sub Jay's, nestled at 11701 New Halls Ferry Road in Florissant, MO, is a true gem for lovers of authentic, hearty BBQ fare. This local eatery is celebrated for its mouthwatering burnt rib tips and the irresistibly savory Rib Tip Sandwich, served without sides to let the rich flavors shine through. Every bite reveals tender, smoky meat with just the right balance of seasoning and sauce, making it an unmissable treat for anyone craving classic Midwestern barbecue.

The menu at Sub Jay's offers a delightful variety, from the generous Subiay's Foot Long Polish Sandwich topped with a hearty portion of MOM's homemade potato salad, to full pans of rib tips—perfect for gatherings or when you simply want to indulge in a feast of bold flavors. Customers can customize their rib tips to enjoy them with or without the signature sauce, ensuring every order is tailored to personal taste. Complement your meal with comforting sides like creamy potato salad, perfectly seasoned green beans, or the unique twist of spaghetti—though some find it a spicier and saucier option than expected, adding an interesting dimension to the plate.

What truly sets Sub Jay’s apart is not just the food, but the warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like visiting a friend's kitchen rather than a restaurant. Longtime patrons like CM Elite praise the familiarity and attentive service, noting how “Mama J ALWAYS get[s] my order right for years,” encapsulating the strong community connection and personalized care customers receive. This sense of home-style hospitality pairs beautifully with the rich, smoky aromas and juicy flavors that fill the air, inviting diners to relax and savor every bite.

Whether you're stopping by for the highly recommended Subjay Sampler Plate—featuring whole wings, beef polish, and rib tips with your choice of two sides—or ordering a full pan to share at a family gathering, the food at Sub Jay’s consistently impresses. The burnt rib tips, in particular, stand out for their tender, juicy texture with a smoky char that makes you “not want to bite your fingers” for fear of losing any of the delicious sauce, as Evette Clayton vividly describes. And don’t skip MOM’s homemade potato salad; it’s a standout side that multiple customers, including Nick Wokurka, say is “worth writing home about.”

Sub Jay’s also works hard to accommodate modern convenience with DoorDash delivery, though some patrons like Tiffany Stewart have noted a few minor wrinkles such as the lack of online side options and slight inconsistencies in the chicken and spaghetti. Yet, these small critiques do little to outweigh the hearty, flavorful experience overall, making this a trusted and beloved destination for BBQ enthusiasts in Florissant and beyond.

In summary, Sub Jay's is not just a restaurant—it’s a flavorful journey into soulful BBQ comfort food with a genuine community spirit. Perfect for both casual lunches and family feasts, it promises generous portions, bold flavors, and a friendly, welcoming environment that keeps patrons coming back time and time again.